“Is the Mulitple Listing Service on the Endangered Species List?”
February 28th, 2008 by Rich JacobsonLast month, Reuters announced that online listing aggregators Yahoo! Real Estate, Zillow, and Trulia had all agreed to adopt a standardized format for the distribution of real estate listings data. This allows the flow of critical information from real estate franchisors, brokers, and MLS agencies to move more quickly and efficiently to consumers.
In his 1993 prophetical “Lions over the Hill” speech, then NAR (National Association of Realtors) President, Bill Chee, predicted that one day the predatory ‘lions’ of technology would come along and prey upon the longstanding and rather complacent gatekeepers of residential market information, the Multiple Listing Services.
According to Wikipedia, “A Multiple Listing Service (MLS) (also Multiple Listing System or Multiple Listings Service) is a group of private databases which allows real estate brokers representing sellers under a listing contract to widely share information about properties with real estate brokers who may represent potential buyers or wish to cooperate with a seller’s broker in finding a buyer for the property. There is no single authoritative “MLS”, and no universal data format. The many local and private databases–some of which are controlled by single associations of realtors or groupings of associations (which represent all brokers within a given community or geographical area) or by real estate brokers–are collectively referred to as the MLS because of their reciprocal access agreements.”
Here in the US, there are over 800+ MLS systems that are owned, operated, and governed by varying private entities (real estate companies, county or regional Board of Realtors, or trade associations). In the past, each of these MLS systems set their own rules for membership, access, and sharing of information. All, however, are subject to nationwide rules laid down by NAR.
Dating back to the 1960′s, the original purpose of the MLS was to simplify the sharing of information from Sellers to Buyers. It was a system that worked back then, and everyone seemed to benefit. Licensed agents were naturally required to contribute a subscription fee to gain access to this listing information.
But times have changed, dramatically. With nearly 85% of consumers accessing the Internet to begin their home buying process, the drive and need for the free flowing access of listing information is forcing the MLS to relinquish their traditional strongholds and concede to growing consumer demands.
The ‘Lions’ are no longer ‘over the hill,’ but they’re in the camp and halfway through their meal!
New competitors such as Google Base, Craigslist, Oodle, and those listed above, are examples of newer alternatives to the MLS service. Recent traffic statistics clearly show that these sites have gained considerable traction and popularity among consumers and real estate professionals.
So with more and more listing data becoming available to the general public, is the MLS headed for the Endangered Species List? What will their proposition of value be to the hundreds of thousands of real estate professionals across the country who are required to contribute to their coffers?
In his speech back in 1993, Mr. Chee predicted that their organization would lose the MLS in just a few, short years. In fact, he gave them less than a 50% chance of stopping that inevitability from happening. He challenged his listeners to change with the times, to embrace emerging technology, and instead ’become’ the Lion!
And now, the vultures are circling the remains….
Share on FacebookNo related posts.















[...] “Is the Mulitple Listing Service on the Endangered Species ListSoundBiteBlog is an award winning Kitsap County Real Estate website created by Mark Flanders and Rich Jacobson. … Last month, Reuters announced that online listing aggregators Yahoo! Real Estate, Zillow, and Trulia had all agreed to adopt a standardized format for the distribution of real estate listings data. [...]
virginia real estate agencies…
Now is the time to invest in US property, Don’t abandon it, invest in it….
Carole: I don’t think the market demand will allow the current MLS system to exist. At the very least, look for someone to introduce a national database/system that all boards can utilize. Once this occurs, then you’ll most likely see a national MLS organization crop up. If the folks at Realtor.com don’t wake up soon, I wouldn’t be surprised if this national organization was led by someone like Google, Yahoo!, Zillow, or a combination thereof.
I agree with Bob; I don’t mind regional cooperation if the laws are the same. Do you really think the model is going to be gone in just a few yrs? I think relinquishing control is something boards are not going to want to do. Again, I agree with Mr. Carney. Why would local control not be necessary, unless all state laws become unified which I would doubt no?
Bob – But what if all these aggregators agreed to standardized rules/guidelines? Just suppose that local control wasn’t necessary. Then what?
But the listing data needs regulated. I don’t think one entity like R.com, google and company can do it. I still think it needs to be local to maintain order by local laws. Regulated feeds should be sent to these sites, Yes, but the sites like P2A and craiglist worry me from a standardized stand point.
Missy – you’re absolutely right. Our value as licensed professionals is not in the listing data (although there still remains some information not yet readily available to the general public here), but in our ability to sort through the data, know our resepective markets intimately, and provide sound, experienced counsel to our clients. Remarkable!
No not yet, but soon. We lost control years ago with R dot com and the horse is out of the gate.
Of course all the sites you mentioned have to get their feeds from somewhere. I think we should charge them more, in Ann Arbor we charge outside vendor 2000.00 for each raw data feed.
Maybe we could charge them a 1.00 per listing. Our value is not in the data anymore but by being Remarkable. LOL